The 11 Best Mattresses of 2025, Tested by Our Editors

Best Overall Mattress

Saatva Classic Mattress

Now 14% Off

Credit: Jamie ProkellProsLuxurious designThree comfort levels to choose fromHolds its shape over timeDurable construction with a long lifespanFree delivery and setup, plus free old mattress/foundation removalConsThe starting price is high, although sales are commonIf you’re a stomach sleeper, a back sleeper, or even a combo sleeper (someone who switches up positions in the night), then Saatva’s Classic Mattress is a phenomenal investment. It comes in three firmness levels: plush soft, luxury firm, and firm. All excellent choices, but we love the luxury firm as a “just right” firmness that’s great for combo sleepers and couples with different sleep styles or mattress preferences.

No matter if you choose the 11.5-inch height or the 14.5-inch height, laying on this mattress will feel every bit as luxurious as a fine hotel bed, and maybe the best part—at least for us—is how green it is as each mattress is made to order, so they don’t sit in storage. The naturally breathable organic cotton cover allows more airflow to help disperse body heat.

“The mattress was delivered on time, and the delivery team was professional and well-presented,” noted our tester. “The Saatva Classic Mattress is a dream. It perfectly balances firmness, support, and softness, delivering lasting comfort throughout the night. Unlike some mattresses that become uncomfortable over time, this one maintains its support, allowing me to wake up feeling refreshed and restored.” They said, “My sleep has noticeably improved. I toss and turn less and stay in deep sleep longer. The mattress cradles me in a way that seems to ease daily stress, making it easier to relax. Once I lay down, I naturally trust that I’ll have a good night’s sleep.”

Other bonuses we enjoyed while testing include a responsive dual-coil design made of recycled carbon steel that’s tempered three times for superb durability. And it’s all assembled in the USA. Saatva’s quality is unparalleled, and even though it’s a bit pricey (especially when not on sale) it’s worth the investment. If you tend to flip-flop between sleeping on your stomach and your back, pick this one up.